I’m truly honored to share; ‘Reciprocating Karma’ – 4th professional’s critique. Another chance taken to get the rapids flowing. Such an unbelievable feeling having my book read by anyone. To have it read by a professional is a dream I never thought would come true. From keeping a promise to becoming a bona fide storyteller, all my expectations are shattered.

In this critique/review, I hope Rachael’s views help readers to dive into the story I created. No amount of thanks can convey how much I appreciate the analysis.

Without you, the reader, travelling the depths of Karma with me, I’d always wonder; ‘What if?’ I thank you for taking an interest in my stories! I’m always interested in how others view my world of Karma. Share your thoughts on the cover design or the story itself via the contact page on my site https://marknistor.com/

Dream big, you just never know what ingredients the universe will add to your journey!

‘Reciprocating Karma’ – 4th Professional’s Critique

Reciprocating Karma: The Universe Giveth & The Universe Taketh by Mark Nistor is a sensational noir crime thriller that elevates the Where’s Your Karma series to electrifying heights. In this fourth instalment, crime and psychological tension is weaved seamlessly into the story’s philosophical core. This offers a unique and relatable take on the crime and psychological thriller genre, providing a high-stakes dangerous drama while facing the possibility of the near certainty of karma- the dreaded consequence of wrong doings.

The plot centers on a terrifying master plan, known as the Twelve Sins of Retribution. Triggered by Ray Rix, a veteran detective whose past mistakes and false imprisonments come back to haunt him. When a series of sinister vigilante attacks exposes a fractured justice system. Mark Nistor’s insight illustrates the devastating outcomes of an individual’s actions that can lead to a string of deadly consequences.

Readers are stirred to contemplate their own set of moral values, ethics and principles in a relatable manner. Nistor’s dramatic narration and descriptions highlight the complexity of karma as well, showing its intricacy beyond the simple ‘good vs evil’. I believe that Karma is a universal law, as do many others.

This story is so intelligent and meaningful. The delicate balance needed to write a criminal and psychological thriller while weaving the gripping intensity and the philosophical mindfulness of an exhilarating plot also about karma, I believe is brilliant. Readers fully see the psychological toll vengeance, revenge and animosity weighs on one’s mind, thoughts and inner being, often poisoning their own soul.

Tensions begin boiling at an all-time high, as secrets unravel. The cycle of revenge intensifies, plunging readers into a dark world of deception and murder. Nistor elevates the story with rich world-building and morally complex characters superbly intertwined while keeping the premise grounded.

Reciprocating Karma by Mark Nistor is a fascinating exploration into showing how far people are willing to go and the risks taken for the sake of revenge and justice. It’s an excellent addition to his tantalizing and awakening series -Where’s Your Karma.

Reciprocating Karma: The Universe Giveth & The Universe Taketh by Mark Nistor will keep readers absorbed and thrilled from start to finish. It comes highly recommended by CLBC-Multi-Genre Literary Group as a believable, thrilling, suspenseful page-turner!
Book reviewed by Rachael Finch for CLBC-Literary Group

CLBC Book Excellence Award for best Crime and Psychological Thriller

‘Reciprocating Karma’ 4th professional’s critique, received May 13th, 2026